Skip to content

Edinburgh Claim Hard Fought Win Over Munster at Musgrave Park

Edinburgh turned the screw in the last quarter to claim a hard fought 18-16 win over a green Munster side at Musgrave Park on Friday evening in what was a decent game of rugby.

As far as starts go, Munster could hardly have gotten off to a worse one. A woeful pass from Nick McCarthy went through Ben Healy’s legs on the goal line at the cost of a five metre scrum.

From the resultant scrum, van der Walt made a decent break. Two phases later and Matt Scott was over form short range. The conversation was added by van der Walt and the victors led 7-0.

It was a largely forgettable opening quarter for the home side who were starved territory or possession. Edinburgh extended the lead in the 21st minute as van der Walt landed a fine kick after a penalty at the scrum.

Munster responded immediately with a good series of carries seeing Edinburgh penalised for not rolling away at the ruck. Healy banished any lingering nerves with a low strike between the posts to reduce the arrears to 7.

Johann van Graan’s side had wrestled back the momentum and when Dan Goggin forced a knock on in defence. The Munster backline pounced. Arnold kicked up to within 10 metres of the Edinburgh line. The chase was superb and forced the penalty for holding on.

Munster secured the line out and a mammoth 23 phases later Tommy O’Donnell was given the try after a consultation from the TMO. 10-10 after Healy converted and a superb response.

Munster forced a early penalty just two minutes after the restart. Ben Healy stepped up to land the kick from well outside the 10 metre line.

Guinness PRO14, Irish Independent Park, Cork 29/11/2019 Munster vs Edinburgh Munster’s Ben Healy kicks a penalty Mandatory Credit ©INPHO/James Crombie

Minutes later and a defensive lapse saw Edinburgh cut a huge hole in the Munster backline as van der Walt broke through. Pierre Schoeman took a pop pass but some superb covering defensive from Munster held the prop up and short of the line.

Munster put in a huge defensive effort to repel the five metre scrum after a sustained Edinburgh attack. Simon Hickey added a 56th minute penalty to cut the gap to just three.

The momentum was beginning to shift back in Edinburgh’s favour and when a sublime cross field kick from Blair Kinghorn caught Wootton just out of position. Eroni Sau pounced and finished to make it 18-16 to the visitors.

Guinness PRO14, Irish Independent Park, Cork 29/11/2019 Munster vs Edinburgh Edinburgh’s Eroni Sau goes past Alex Wootton of Munster to scores his sides second try Mandatory Credit ©INPHO/James Crombie

The Scottish side manage to see out the remaining 17 minutes of the game excellently to keep Munster at bay. In fairness the home side never seriously threatened in the final quarter.

For their part, Munster just couldn’t get the required possession or field position for put them in range for go-ahead penalty. It was a disappointing end to what was a largely positive performance.

Social Sharing

Posted in

WATCH: O’Mahony on “complete rugby team” Saracens

It's do or die for Munster tomorrow as they welcome Saracens to Thomond Park for Round 3 of ...
Read More

WATCH: Keith Earls’ Champions Cup campaign so far

Keith Earls has been in flying form for Munster since his return from a subdued Rugby World Cup. ...
Read More

WATCH: “No weaknesses in the squad”-van Graan wary of Saracens threat

Although they have named a weakened side for this Saturday's game, Saracens will come to Thomond Park tomorrow ...
Read More

WATCH: JJ Hanrahan focused on home Saracens test

Saracens travel to Thomond Park this weekend for a crucial Champions Cup clash. The winner on Saturday will ...
Read More

Saracens team for Thomond trip Announced

Saracens Head Coach Mark McCall has named his Saracens team for this Saturday's Champions Cup clash with Munster ...
Read More

Munster Name Team for Saracens Clash in Thomond

The Munster side has been named for Saturday’s vital Champions Cup clash against Saracens at Thomond Park (5.30pm). ...
Read More

WATCH: ‘What more do you want’-CJ Stander excited for Saracens clash

Munster have the chance to put daylight between themselves and Saracens in the Champions Cup this Saturday in ...
Read More

WATCH: Stander praises Munster’s evolving style of play

Munster take on Saracens this Saturday in the Champions CUp in Thomond Park. Munster currently lead Saracens in ...
Read More