“There’s no reason for women to be treated differently to men in any walk of life” | Gearoid Hegarty hoping for Yes vote at Congress

Geroid Hegarty has won it all in the intercounty landscape. Three All-Ireland medals are accompanied by as many provincial titles with Limerick without doubt at the top of the hurling landscape.

The St Patricks man is one of only two Limerick players to win the All-Star Hurler of the Year award which he captured in 2020 after a stellar season.

His long term girlfriend Niamh McCarthy has also won a share of titles, helping her home club Dromcollogher Broadford to successive Intermediate Football titles last December while also captaining the Limerick side for two years.

Yet, in a column for the GPA on their website today, Hegarty outlined the huge differences between the treatment of male and female players in today’s society as he urged people to vote yes at the GAA congress to integrate with the Camogie Association and Ladies Football association.

“Do male members of the GAA actually understand the differences in terms of how our female counterparts are treated in comparison to us? I do because I see it all the time.  My girlfriend Niamh plays football for Dromcollogher/Broadford and captained Limerick as they reached the Junior All-Ireland semi-final in 2020.

“She has since drawn a line under her inter-county career.  Was that solely down to how female athletes in our games are treated?  No.  But did the way female athletes in our games are treated make her decision easier?  Definitely.  It’s so much easier to just say I’m not going to bother anymore, which is a shame but understandable.

“Here’s just one example of what she has been through.  Niamh won the intermediate football title in Limerick last year, qualifying for a Munster quarter-final.  That game was scheduled for the same weekend as the Limerick camogie finals.  A number of dual players were involved.  They were told that they would have to make a choice and wouldn’t be considered for the camogie final on the Sunday if they played the football quarter-final on the Friday night.

Imagine 21 and 22-year-olds being put in that position.  Missing players, they lost the football game.  That sickened Niamh as you don’t get too many goes at winning Munster.  A lot of those girls have now gone to Australia so the likelihood is they won’t get another chance.

“The management teams involved were doing the best for the teams they were in charge of but ultimately it comes down to two separate governing bodies in the female codes. That wouldn’t happen in the men’s codes as a solution would have been found by the GAA.

“These kinds of things occur too regularly.  We saw it just this week where Slaughtneil from Derry and Sarsfields from Galway were taken all the way to Gorey in Wexford to play in an All-Ireland club semi-final.  An All-Ireland semi-final!

“Who, first of all, is in charge of fixing the game?  The Camogie Association, who were trying their absolute best, but who have to rely on the use of facilities from others.  If there was equal access to facilities under one association that would not have to happen.  I always come back to the point it would never happen on the men’s side and that’s not good enough in today’s society.”

Limerick Ladies Football captain Niamh McCarthy after their 2020 All-Ireland Ladies Junior Football League win over Carlow

Hegarty highlighted the disparity in resources made available to his side in comparison to that of McCarthy’s when it comes issues off the field such as physios and fixtures with the difference striking.

“If you just look at a baseline of how women are treated compared to how men are treated there’s a massive chasm.  That’s from fixture clashes to access to facilities to female players being asked to pay to play.  They have to ask themselves; Can I afford it?

“It also permeates the minimum standards of care male and female players are exposed to.  Niamh experienced the situation where there was no doctor or physio at training sessions.  That, to me, is a disgrace.  There needs to be at least one of those there every night.  That’s a non-negotiable.  I wouldn’t accept it at our training sessions.

“I’m in a very privileged position.  We are literally left wanting for nothing.  We arrive to training and everything is laid out for us and all I have to do is turn up and get out on the field.  Everything else looked after from basics like a nice hot shower to hot food to recovery shakes.  There are physios there and a doctor.

“For our game days too, we literally just turn up.  That’s the hardest thing we’re asked to do outside of actually playing the game.  That’s really all a player should have to worry about but it’s not the case for my female counterparts.  They don’t even know where they will be playing sometimes just days before big matches.  It would never happen on the men’s side of things. That’s the major point that I always come back to.  In this day and age, it’s not good enough to say things like that.”

22 August 2021; Gearóid Hegarty of Limerick celebrates after scoring his side’s first goal during the GAA Hurling All-Ireland Senior Championship Final match between Cork and Limerick in Croke Park, Dublin. Photo by Harry Murphy/Sportsfile

The St Patricks club man concluded his statement with a plea to those voting to opt yes to not only improve the treatment to female players but to also send out a broader message as, “there’s no reason for women to be treated differently to men in any walk of life including the games we all love.”

“For all of those reasons I want to see the GPA motion for integration passed this weekend at GAA Congress.  But, as a teacher who deals with young people every day, there’s more to it than that.

“I think it could be an incredibly powerful message. It could actually transcend sporting boundaries; the leading sporting and cultural organisation in Ireland (in my opinion the leading organisation in Ireland full stop) saying that men and women are to be treated equally from now on.  In terms of the message that sends out about respect between boys and girls, it’s massive.

“That’s the way it should be and I’d be hopeful that the motion will get passed overwhelmingly. We’re in 2022 now, and there’s no reason for women to be treated differently to men in any walk of life including the games we all love.”

This Saturday, February 26, the GAA’s Annual Congress will take place in the NUI Galway Connacht GAA Airdome. A total of 48 motions will go before the delegates to be debated and voted on.

Motion 33 comes from the GPA. It calls on the GAA to prioritise integration with the LGFA and the Camogie asociation. This motion, if passed, would not result in a change in the rules. One of the functions of Congress is to direct the Association with regard to fundamental policy matters and that’s what this in effect will do if the motion is passed.


To read Hegarty’s piece in full head to the GPA website or click here!

Social Sharing

Posted in

FIXTURES | Round Three of Football Championships commences this weekend after five-week break

It's been over a month since round two of the football championship due to the return of hurling. ...
Read More

PIHC Round Up | Bruff and Glenroe level at the top after third round action

Each of the eight teams were in action for the third successive weekend with the table beginning to ...
Read More

HIGHLIGHTS | A goal fest between the Limerick and Tipperary Legends as the Shannonsiders prevail

The legends from both counties joined forces to raise money for a very worthy cause on Saturda afternoon. ...
Read More

FIXTURES | Second Round of games set for 3Dental Ladies Football Championships

Following an eventful opening weekend, the second round of the 3Dental senior, intermediate, junior A and junior B ...
Read More

Treaty Talk EP195 | Club Hurling Championship Second Round Review & 2022 Top 10 Hurlers

Episode 195 of the podcast has a special guest with Matt O'Callaghan on holidays. Jack Neville is joined ...
Read More

PREVIEW | Newcastle West and Monaleen prepare for fascinating battle in Premier Intermediate Championship

The Rathkeale of the clash is the third of four games in the championship this weekend. Monaleen and ...
Read More

HIGHLIGHTS | Bruff overcome sloppy start to see of Dromin Athlacca in PIHC

Bruff and Dromin Athlacca played out an entertaining game in front of the Limerick GAA TV cameras on ...
Read More

Sporting Limerick to livestream legends charity clash between Tipperary and Limerick

The game takes place on Saturday afternoon in Boher with all proceeds going to Crumlin Children's hospital. "Old ...
Read More