Skip to content

OPINION: World Rugby must keep integrity of competition.

Some of this weekends Rugby World Cup 2019 fixtures are under threat, leaving many fans, pundits and media in the unknown as the dangers of Typhoon Hagibis are potentially huge.

So much so that the current World Rugby regulations in place would affect the balance of competitive Sport should games get cancelled.

Let’s focus on the potential issues from an Irish perspective in Pool A as an example.

2019 Rugby World Cup Pool A, International Stadium, Yokohama, Japan 22/9/2019 Ireland vs Scotland Ireland’s Andrew Conway scores their fourth try despite Grant Gilchrist of Scotland Mandatory Credit ©INPHO/Craig Mercer

The worry for Ireland fans is the fact that their game on Saturday against the Samoans hangs in the balance due to the storm.

As of now, should Ireland’s final pool game be called off because of the weather, then the game would be declared a 0-0 draw and both teams would be awarded two points each as per current World Rugby regulations.

The same cancellation call would be made for the Japan v Scotland clash on Sunday which is also believed to be stuck in the crosshairs of the ‘Super Typhoon’.

Should both games be cancelled and declared draws it would see Japan top Pool A with 16 points and Ireland finish second on 13 points.

Scotland kept their Rugby World Cup quarter-final hopes alive with a crushing win over Russia. Credit Getty Images

The current rules in place would completely scupper Scotland’s chances, as the minimum requirement for their game against the Brave Blossoms is nothing short of bonus-point victory in order to give themselves a chance of progression. Two points from a draw would leave them on 12 points and third place.

I can see the initial logic from World Rugby’s point of view, but at this moment in time, three teams in Pool A have it all to play for and if the games were to be called off and declared draws it would stain the whole tournament.

The people of Japan have embraced this tournament and welcomed all travelling support. The public transport is second to none, the food is out of this world and of course, the Rugby and the stadium atmosphere has looked inviting from afar.

While Mother Nature cannot be stopped, World Rugby should change their regulations and delay the games affected by Typhoon Hagibis by 24 – 48 hours so they can be played.

Therefore Ireland, Japan and Scotland can take to the field and earn their place in World Rugby’s last eight. While World Rugby can keep their integrity intact when it comes to the running of a major tournament.

Social Sharing

Posted in

WATCH: Van Graan on Ireland’s World Cup exit & update on Cloete

Munster Head Coach Johann van Graan gave his thoughts on Ireland's defeat to the All Blacks last weekend ...
Read More

WATCH: James Cronin on wearing the Highfield colours once again

Munster Prop James Cronin spoke to the media this week about playing for his club Highfield RFC last ...
Read More

WATCH: Van Graan on dealing with own RWC Disappointment in 2015

Munster Head Coach Johann van Graan spoke to the media this week about dealing with his own Rugby ...
Read More

WATCH: Neil Cronin on family World Cup disappointment and taking his chances

Neil Cronin had more than a passing eye on Ireland's progress in the Word Cup. Not only was ...
Read More

WATCH: James Cronin on the long road back to fitness and injury frustration

James Cronin made his long awaited return to action during pre-season for Munster and is looking to make ...
Read More

WATCH: Van Graan on lifting the spirits of the Irish players when they return

Munster head coach Johann van Graan says that it will be a challenge to lift the spirits of ...
Read More

Junior Rugby Roundup: Challenge Cup wins for Richmond, Abbeyfeale and Newcastle West

With six local clubs paired against each other, the opening round of the Munster Junior Challenge Cup at ...
Read More

WATCH: Tough day at the office for Limerick’s AIL teams

Shannon were the only victors from Limerick's AIL teams in action today as they came away with a ...
Read More