Opinion: Should suspensions carry into All-Ireland Finals?

On Sunday last, Waterford turned in a tremendous performance to overturn Munster champions Cork and reach a first All-Ireland Final since 2008. Earlier this summer, Cork defeated favourites Waterford in the Munster semi-final with Cork simply too good for the Déise on the day.

The roles were reversed last Sunday with the Waterford underdogs blitzing Cork for four goals as their quest to win a first All-Ireland huring title since 1958 gained serious momentum. Next up is a Galway side who have been hugely impressive so far this summer and will head into the final as favourites.

Despite the victory, it wasnt the impending final that dominated discussions. Instead much of the post-match focus revolved around an incident late in the first half.

Reigning hurler of the year Austin Gleeson got tangled with Cork’s Luke Meade on the touchline and both men fell to the floor as the ball rolled out of play. As Gleeson got up however, he appeared to pull the helmet off Meade. Despite Gleeson’s eyes not looking towards Meade, there was a clear tug on the helmet from the Mount Sion man.

Gleeson knew he was in trouble and drifted out of the game until a late spree, including a wonder goal helped secure victory for Waterford. After the match, pundits and fans alike pondered whether Gleeson would be cleared to play in the final or would we be robbed of seeing arguably the finest hurler in the land strut his stuff on the biggest day of the year.

As things would pan out, it was announced yesterday evening that Gleeson had been cleared to play, which caused a major difference of opinions to say the least.

In adddition to the Austin incident, his namesake Conor Gleeson received a straight red card in the 69th minute for a pull on Patrick Horgan. Gleeson is clearly seen to strike the Corkman and there was no doubt about the referes decision. Conor Gleeson had been immense on the day, man-marking Conor Lehane and leaving him with little time or space throughout the game.

Lehane who had been arguably the player of the Munster Championship, was hardly seen all day at Headquarters. Conor Gleeson would be the ideal man to man-mark one of Galway’s flyers up front.

These incidents have brought up the question, Should suspensions carry into finals. Some would argue that these players are grown men and should know better than to act recklessly with so much at stake. Yet, at the same time, things could have worked out differently and Waterford would have been without two of their key men.

In Austin’s case, his pull of the helemt, although against the law, was harmless in its essence. Conor on the other hand was malicious in his action and here may lie the key in future decisions.

With three major incidents involving helmets in the last three high profile hurling games, it is time to address the ruling surrounding helmets. The law surrounding helmets is clear but its interpretation has been inconsistent and frustration for players and managers alike.

Just ask Tadgh De Búrca or Adrian Tuohy. For largely similar incidents, De Búrca was sent off and missed Waterford’s thrilling victory, whilst no action was taken against Tuohy in Galway’s triumph over Tipperary.

Social Sharing

Posted in

Limerick learn McGrath Cup opponents as 2023 fixtures are revealed

Limerick will be under new management for the first time since 2017 as Ray Dempsey makes his debut ...
Read More

Fixtures confirmed for Newcastle West and Na Piarsaigh’s Munster Football Finals

Both sides secured safe passage to their respective provincial finals over the weekend with wins over Tipperary opposition. ...
Read More

PREVIEW | Intermediate Hurling Championship decider between Croagh-Kilfinny and Na Piarsaigh takes place this weekend

Both teams were successful in their respective semi-final clashes which were played on the 23rd of October. The ...
Read More

PREVIEW | St. Kieran’s face Cork’s Ballygiblin in Munster Junior Hurling Club Championship this weekend

Kieran's overcame Clare opposition Banner in the semi-final with a dramatic 0-17 to 0-16 victory after extra-time. St. ...
Read More

Preview | Munster championship at stake for Monaleen in Intermediate Hurling Final against Roscrea

The City side have already went one better than their previous Munster championship in 2016 where they lost ...
Read More

“It’s hectic but brilliant” | Declan Hannon on return to round robin, team holiday and Harty Cup

Declan Hannon was in attendance at the unveiling of eir as a new official sponsor of the GAA ...
Read More

Declan Hannon helps launch new official sponsor of All-Ireland Senior Hurling Championship

Limerick will be bidding for four in a row next summer as they attempt to retain their stranglehold ...
Read More

HIGHLIGHTS | Newcastle West avenge defeat of 2015 in Munster semi-final triumph against Clonmel Commercials

The Magpies will now face Kerrins O'Rahilly's in a fortnight's time to contest for the Munster Senior Football ...
Read More